Thanksgiving is Thursday, November 26, and the first pie order deadline in our area is today. If you want a pie you didn't bake yourself on the table, this is the week to call.
We went through every shop's 2026 Thanksgiving menu so you don't have to. Below are eight spots in Greenwich and just over the line, what each one is baking this year, and exactly when to order. Everything here comes from the shops' own sites, so you can order with confidence.
Most shops cap holiday orders, so earlier is always better.
In Greenwich
1. Aux Délices, Greenwich + Riverside — The easy Greenwich order. The holiday menu covers every classic: double-crusted apple made with Honeycrisp, Empire and Granny Smith apples, apple crumb, classic pumpkin, and a pecan pie made with Grade A maple syrup and Georgia pecans. There's a gluten-free apple crisp too. Add their chocolate turkey cake if there are kids at the table. How to order: online, for pickup Monday, Nov. 23 through Wednesday, Nov. 25, or free home delivery on Wednesday, Nov. 25. Where: 3 W. Elm St., Greenwich
2. Garelick & Herbs, Greenwich — The longest pie list in town, with plenty of dairy-free and nut-free picks for guests with restrictions. This year: blueberry peach lattice, apple crumb, cranberry apple, mixed berry, coconut custard, chocolate pecan, pumpkin and traditional apple, all in 10-inch rounds. How to order: preorder online for pickup Nov. 23 to 25. Where: 48 W. Putnam Ave., Greenwich
3. Black Forest Pastry Shop, Greenwich — The German bakery off the Avenue has been here since 1982 and still bakes its pies from the same recipes it started with. There are twelve this year, in 8 or 10 inch: pumpkin (their top seller), apple, apple crumb, pecan, chocolate pecan, cherry, blueberry, peach, strawberry rhubarb, coconut custard, chocolate cream and banana cream. How to order: by Sunday, Nov. 22, online or at 203-629-9330. Closed Thanksgiving Day. Where: 52 Lewis St., Greenwich
4. By The Way Bakery, Greenwich — Everything here is gluten-free, dairy-free and kosher, so it works for almost every table. The Thanksgiving lineup is three tarts, ginger pumpkin, apple and pecan, plus a dairy-free pumpkin cheesecake. How to order: by Friday, Nov. 20. Where: 19 E. Putnam Ave., Greenwich
Just Over the Line
5. Patisserie Salzburg, Rye — A European-style patisserie that bakes its tarts and pies on site every day. The Rye menu lists a French apple tart, an almond and pear tart, and apple, blueberry and pumpkin pies. How to order: call ahead for holiday orders. Where: 2 Second St., Rye
6. Rye Country Store, Rye — A Purchase Street staple for almost 80 years, with pies in 6, 8 and 10 inch. The 2026 list: pecan, chocolate bourbon pecan, pumpkin, apple or apple crumb, blueberry or blueberry crumb, cherry, mincemeat and coconut custard. How to order: by Wednesday, Nov. 18 (today) for Wednesday, Nov. 25 pickup, at 914-967-3450 or ryecountrystore@aol.com. Where: 41 Purchase St., Rye
7. Palmer's Market, Darien — Scratch-made, all-butter pies from Palmer's own bakery. Choose from mile high apple, maple pecan, pumpkin, cherry, apple cranberry crumb, chocolate cream, lemon meringue and a pear almond tart. How to order: online or at 203-655-2077 by Friday, Nov. 20 at 5 p.m. In-store pickup only, Wednesday, Nov. 25. Closed Thanksgiving Day. Where: 264 Heights Rd., Darien
8. Rosie, New Canaan — A short, very good list made with Connecticut apples and pears: apple, pumpkin made with fresh pumpkin, brown butter pecan, and pear and cranberry crumble. Each pie is $60. How to order: by Sunday, Nov. 22 at 3 p.m., at 203-966-8998 or info@rosienewcanaan.com. Pickup is Wednesday, Nov. 25, between 2 and 4 p.m. Where: 27 Elm St., New Canaan
Know Your Deadlines — Screenshot this one. Most shops cap holiday orders, so earlier is always better.
